Understanding EU data protection policy
Summary
The 'datafication' of everyday life and various data scandals have made the protection of personal data an increasingly important social, legal and political topic for the European Union (EU). Privacy and data protection are recognised as fundamental rights in EU law and were strengthened when the Lisbon Treaty came into force in 2009, giving the EU a stronger legal basis for updating its data protection and privacy system.
In 2012, the European Commission began reforming the outdated framework. This led to the adoption of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the Law Enforcement Directive, along with updates to EU institutional data protection rules, in 2016 and 2018. The European Parliament played a key role in these reforms, both as co‑legislator and author of own‑initiative reports and resolutions, seeking to guarantee a high level of data protection for EU citizens. The Court of Justice of the EU further developed the EU data protection framework through case law.
Nevertheless, new concerns have emerged under the updated data protection framework. These relate to shortcomings in GDPR enforcement, tensions between compliance and competitiveness, difficulties in reconciling security‑related data access with privacy protection, and the risk of overburdening small and medium‑sized enterprises with compliance requirements. In response, EU lawmakers adopted GDPR procedural rules for cross‑border cases, and introduced a temporary derogation from the e‑Privacy Directive to combat online child sexual abuse. Meanwhile, the Commission has proposed a permanent framework intended to replace the temporary rules, and a digital omnibus regulation easing certain data protection requirements in support of competitiveness and artificial intelligence development. It also appears to be preparing a legislative initiative on data retention.
This is a further updated edition of a briefing originally written in 2020 by Sofija Voronova and previously updated most recently in 2025.
Introduction
As early as 2012, the European Commission pointed to an emerging 'brave new data world' to justify the need for data protection reform, which led to the adoption of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). These concerns materialised forcefully in 2018, just months before the GDPR began to apply, when the Cambridge Analytica scandal revealed the real‑world consequences of large‑scale online tracking and profiling. Cambridge Analytica claimed that it used psychographic analysis to target micro‑audiences with personalised messages, highlighting how the individualisation of information environments can shape, steer, or even manipulate personal behaviour, including voting behaviour and consumer decisions. The volume of data being produced worldwide was estimated to grow from 33 zettabytes in 2018, to 175 zettabytes in 2025 and to 527.5 zettabytes in 2029 (one zettabyte equals 1021 bytes, or one thousand billion gigabytes).
Recently, voices have surfaced advocating a more permissive approach to data processing by data‑intensive technologies, such as artificial intelligence (AI), as well as by law enforcement authorities. Proponents suggest that the expected economic and societal benefits of AI outweigh data protection risks. Similarly, law enforcement agencies contend that criminals increasingly exploit digital technologies and applications to plan and commit offences, thereby justifying broader powers for storing and accessing user data.
Public sentiment
Heightened awareness of privacy breaches, increased use of online social networks, and a rise in the public exercise of data rights all indicate the growing relevance of data protection for EU citizens. In 2023, 90.27 % of people in the EU between the ages of 16 and 74 used the internet daily. In a 2024 special Eurobarometer survey on the Digital Decade, respondents identified the misuse of personal data (46 %) as the issue having the greatest personal impact among challenges relating to digital technologies. The Consumer Conditions Scoreboard 2025 revealed that a clear majority of respondents who purchase online (71 %) reported concerns about the collection of personal data without consent in the context of online targeted advertising. The European Consumer Organisation (BEUC) 2023 survey found that 60 % of consumer respondents considered personal data analysis and monetisation to be unfair. During the Conference on the Future of Europe (2021‑2022), citizens panels called for a high level of data protection and stringent implementation.
Legal framework
Historical developments
A right to protection of personal information or data is not a recent phenomenon in Europe. After World War II, the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights included a right to freedom from 'arbitrary interference with ... privacy, family, home or correspondence', while the 1950 European Convention on Human Rights included a right to respect for private and family life. In 1970, the German Land of Hessen introduced the first law in Europe to specifically address protection of personal data. Sweden introduced the first national data protection laws in 1973, followed by Germany in 1977 and France in 1978. These laws were introduced both in response to surveillance regimes imposed by the state (Germany) and as an expression of a strong privacy culture (France and Sweden). In May 1975, the European Parliament adopted a resolution on the rights of individuals to data protection, stating that protection of these rights was a Member State responsibility. The 1980s saw attempts to approximate the growing number of national personal data protection laws through adoption of Organisation for Economic Co‑operation and Development (OECD) guidelines in 1980 and a Council of Europe convention in 1981. The latter, referred to as Convention 108, was the first binding international instrument to protect individuals against potential rights abuses arising in the course of data processing. It was signed by all Council of Europe members (including all EU Member States), and by Argentina, Cabo Verde, Mauritius, Mexico, Morocco, Senegal, Tunisia and Uruguay, and was updated by Protocol CETS No 223 in October 2018. In 1995, the Data Protection Directive 95/46/EC (DPD) became the first and main EU legal instrument protecting personal data prior to the GDPR. The DPD was aimed at improving the internal market and addressing fundamental rights protection gaps in Member State laws.
Data protection reforms
In 2012, the European Commission proposed a data protection reform package that included a reform of the DPD (giving birth to the GDPR) and a draft directive on data processing for law enforcement purposes (since its adoption referred to as the Law Enforcement Directive). The Commission considered an overhaul of the rules to be necessary for achieving a greater degree of harmonisation (estimated at the time to save approximately €2.3 billion a year for companies in administrative burden alone), and for ensuring that the right to personal data protection could be upheld in 'today's new challenging digital environment'.
The GDPR (Regulation 2016/679) entered into force on 24 May 2016, but did not fully apply until 25 May 2018, giving businesses, organisations and public authorities two years to meet their new obligations. The Law Enforcement Directive 2016/680 entered into effect in May 2016, with a similar two‑year timeframe for implementation; it had to be transposed into national laws by 6 May 2018. In January 2017, the Commission launched proposals for a regulation on data protection in the EU institutions and a regulation on e-privacy, focusing on electronic communications. Regulation 2018/1725 on data protection by EU institutions entered into force in November 2018. By contrast, negotiations on the e‑privacy reform stalled leading to the proposal's withdrawal on 6 October 2025.
General Data Protection Regulation
The GDPR is the most high‑profile and well‑known EU legal instrument on data protection.
Principles. The GDPR is a technologically neutral legal instrument, as the same rules apply to companies and organisations regardless of the techniques used to collect or process data; Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) case law has confirmed this interpretation. It is not sector‑specific, although sector‑specific rules exist for law enforcement and electronic communications. Academics and regulators consider the GDPR a risk‑based regulation, where the achievement of its policy objectives (i.e. free movement of data and fundamental‑rights protection) is sought by targeting the regulation of activities that pose the highest risks to attaining those objectives.
Scope. According to Article 3(2) of the GDPR, this regulation's rules apply to companies regardless of whether or not the data processing takes place in the EU; this is sometimes referred to as 'extraterritoriality'. Protection extends to EU residents, i.e. both EU citizens and non‑citizens who are resident in the EU. Only personal data fall within the scope of GDPR protection. Data are considered 'personal' when they can directly or indirectly allow identification of a natural person, such as through a name, an identity (ID) number or location data. The CJEU has classified an IP address and written answers submitted by a candidate in an exam as personal data.
Lawful grounds for processing data. To be subject to GDPR obligations, the processing of personal data does not necessarily have to be performed by automated means, and can include collecting, recording, organising, storing, using, consulting, making available, or erasing data.
Processing can only be carried out on the basis of one of six specified legal grounds in Article 6 of the GDPR. These are (i) 'freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous' consent of the data subject (i.e. the person whose data is being processed); (ii) performance of a contract; (iii) compliance with a legal obligation; (iv) protection of the 'vital interests' of the data subject; (v) performance of a task in the public interest; or (vi) legitimate interests that override the fundamental rights of the data subject. The processing of particularly sensitive data, such as race, political opinions, religious beliefs, or biometric data, is generally prohibited by the GDPR, but its Article 9(2) sets out some exceptions (e.g. explicit consent of the data subject, protection of vital interests of the data subject, data made public by the data subject, substantial public interest).
Data rights. Chapter III of the GDPR sets out data subjects' rights, including the right: to know what data a company has collected about them if they request them (right of access); to have wrong information corrected; and to request the deletion of any data not required to be kept for specific reasons, such as public interest (the right to be forgotten, also known as the right to erasure); to limit the controllers' uses of their data (see Box 1 below); the newly introduced right to data portability; and the right not to be subject to automated individual decision‑making.
New obligations for companies include notification of a personal data breach to controllers and data protection authorities (DPAs) within 72 hours, and the designation of a data protection officer whose tasks include advising the controller and processor and cooperating with the relevant DPA. On 14 December 2021, the European Data Protection Board adopted its final guidelines on examples of personal data breach notifications.
Box 1 – Controllers and processors
The GDPR refers to the businesses, organisations and other entities collecting or processing data as 'controllers' or 'processors'. Controllers determine the purposes and means of processing, while processors process the personal data on behalf of the controllers. Controllers and processors without an establishment in the EU must designate a representative within its territory.
Two or more controllers can be involved in determining the means of processing, and are referred to as 'joint controllers'. Despite the Fashion ID judgment confirming that a website featuring a Facebook 'Like' button can be a joint controller with Facebook, confusion has persisted over the delineation of responsibilities between joint controllers. The Council of the EU has called on the DPAs and the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) to clarify these rules. On 2 September 2020, the EDPB adopted guidelines on these concepts, which were further updated in July 2021.
The DPAs (also referred to as supervisory authorities or SAs) are independent public authorities responsible for supervising and monitoring the application of data protection laws in their territory. Their powers, tasks and responsibilities are set out in full in Chapter VI Section 2 of the GDPR, which expanded these powers considerably. Consequently, the DPAs' new powers include investigative powers for unannounced inspections and the powers to fine a company up to 4 % of their total worldwide annual turnover for certain infringements. The DPAs provide expert advice on data protection issues and handle complaints regarding breaches of the GDPR or other relevant legislation. The 1995 Data Protection Directive introduced a decentralised enforcement system requiring that each Member State have its own DPA(s), which the GDPR maintains. The GDPR establishes a 'one-stop shop mechanism' allowing companies to deal with a single DPA in cross‑border data protection cases. Once Regulation 2025/2518 becomes applicable on 2 April 2027, DPAs must follow the procedural rules set out therein.
The EDPB. The GDPR establishes a new European Data Protection Board (EDPB) to replace the Article 29 Working Party (AW29) as the independent legal body bringing together representatives of all Member State DPAs and the European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS). The EDPB's key responsibilities include adopting binding decisions on certain matters, advising the Commission on third‑country data transfer agreements and issuing own‑initiative or requested reports on best practice for the consistent application of the GDPR.
Remedies. Data subjects can lodge a complaint against a controller or a processor, or can mandate a not‑for‑profit body or organisation to lodge the complaint on their behalf. Complaints can also be lodged against a DPA where it fails to handle a complaint or inform the data subject about the progress of their complaint within three months of it being lodged. Compensation is available for individuals who have suffered material or non‑material damage. Article 80(2) of the GDPR, in conjunction with national legislation, allows non‑governmental organisations (NGOs) to pursue collective rights actions without requiring a direct mandate by individuals. According to a non‑binding opinion of Advocate General Richard de la Tour, Article 80(2) of the GDPR does not preclude Member States from empowering associations to plead objective breaches of data protection law without there being a need to claim the existence of actual cases affecting named individuals. Civil society and consumer organisations consider these provisions particularly important for making GDPR protection a 'reality for individuals' and for contributing to the development of harmonised jurisprudence and implementation of the GDPR.
In July 2024, the Commission issued its second report on the application of the GDPR.
Data processing for law enforcement purposes
The Law Enforcement Directive or LED (Directive 2016/680) has applied fully since 6 May 2018. It belongs to the same data protection reform package as the GDPR and aims to protect personal data when processed by Member State police or law enforcement and criminal justice authorities, and to improve cooperation in the fight against terrorism and cross‑border crime. The directive covers both personal data‑processing at domestic level and cross‑border sharing of personal data between Member States. Obligations for governments include establishing time limits for the erasure of personal data or arranging for a regular review of the need to store such data. Rights of individuals include the right to have certain information made available to them by law enforcement authorities, including the name and contact details of the controller and the reasons for which their data are being processed, as well as the right to request access to and correction or deletion of their personal data. The Commission identified 10 legal acts that required further alignment with the LED. In July 2023, the Commission published its first report on the application and functioning of the LED.
Data protection in the EU institutions
Regulation 2018/1725 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data by the Union's institutions, bodies, offices and agencies and on the free movement of such data updates the data protection rules for data processing by EU institutions and bodies, to align them with the provisions of the GDPR and the Law Enforcement Directive. This regulation also establishes the formal duties of the EDPS, the authority responsible for ensuring the effective protection of individuals' rights when their personal data are processed by or on behalf of EU institutions and bodies (Article 52(1) and (3) of the regulation). The other tasks of the EDPS are set out in Article 57 of the regulation and include promoting public awareness of the risks, rules, and rights in relation to processing, particularly for activities involving children, and monitoring the development of technologies that have an impact on personal data protection. In October 2022, the Commission published its first report on the Data Protection Regulation for EU institutions.
e‑Privacy legislation
Directive 2002/58/EC concerning the processing of personal data and the protection of privacy in the electronic communications sector (the e‑Privacy Directive) is aimed at harmonising national provisions and providing specific rules for electronic communications services. Unlike the GDPR, the e‑Privacy Directive applies to the data of both natural and legal persons (i.e. individuals and companies), and applies specifically to the data processed in connection with the provision of electronic communications services. In January 2017, the Commission tabled a proposal for an e‑privacy regulation to replace the directive. The proposed regulation aimed to achieve greater harmonisation, define clearer rules for tracking technologies, such as cookies, and expand the scope of the directive1 to include internet‑based communications services that do not rely on traditional networks (OTT services). While the European Parliament adopted its position in October 2017, the discussions in the Council were stalled for approximately four years. After several redrafts, the Member States agreed on a mandate for negotiation with Parliament, and trilogue negotiations began on 20 May 2021. In contrast to Parliament's position, the Council proposes to broaden exceptions to the general prohibition on processing electronic communications data, to expand the grounds for the collection of information from end users' terminal equipment, and to legitimise the practice of making access to websites conditional on consent or payment ('cookie walls'). While industry trade associations welcomed the Council's position, civil rights organisations urged the European Parliament to push back and ensure a high level of privacy and confidentiality. The EDPB considered that the Council position risked lowering the protection standard below the pre‑existing standard under the e‑Privacy Directive. The German Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information was 'stunned' by the 'severe interferences with citizens' fundamental rights' and warned that several 'red lines in the area of data protection would be crossed'. Negotiations on the e‑privacy reform were blocked several times throughout negotiations; the Commission withdrew the proposal on 6 October 2025 due to a lack of progress.
Data protection outside the EU
EU data protection rules apply to the European Economic Area (EEA), which includes all EU Member States plus Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway. When personal data are transferred outside the EEA, safeguards in Chapter V of the GDPR must be fulfilled to ensure that protection travels with the data.
Data transfers
Adequacy decisions. Article 45 of the GDPR regulates the most convenient and cost‑effective mechanism to transfer data to third countries outside the EEA. Where the European Commission, by means of an implementing decision on data adequacy, recognises that a foreign country's level of data protection is essentially equivalent to that of the EU, economic operators may conveniently transfer data to the importing entity located in a third country. The adoption of an adequacy decision requires: a proposal from the Commission; a non‑binding opinion from the EDPB; approval from Member State representatives, and the final adoption of the decision by the Commission. Parliament and the Council can, at any time, request the Commission to maintain, amend or withdraw an adequacy decision, whenever they perceive the Commission to have exceeded its implementing powers. Adequacy decisions are to be reviewed at least every four years. In 2024, the Commission reviewed 12 existing adequacy decisions positively.
Box 2 – Data protection and Brexit
To sustain the flow of personal data between the EU and the UK, the Commission adopted two UK adequacy decisions following the UK's withdrawal from the EU. The draft adequacy decision of 2021 was already heavily criticised by Parliament and commentators. After two failed attempts by Conservative governments, the Labour government succeed in reforming the UK data protection and privacy framework in June 2025. Despite criticism that the UK's data protection standard would fall short of the EU's, the Commission renewed the UK's adequacy decision until 27 December 2031. A determination of non‑adequacy would have had costly implications for both jurisdictions.
So far, the Commission has approved adequacy decisions for 15 non‑EU countries, including the United Kingdom (see Box 2), and the European Patent Organisation. The Commission has referred to adequacy decisions as 'digital diplomacy', while Parliament stressed that the decision should not be political but legal. Data exchanges in the law enforcement sector are covered by the Law Enforcement Directive adequacy mechanism.
Alternative transfer tools. Adequacy decisions are not the only means for transferring personal data outside the EEA. Other GDPR tools include binding corporate rules, standard data protection clauses adopted by the Commission, and approved codes of conduct and certification mechanisms for processors and controllers. The Council has noted that these tools sometimes 'better meet the needs of individual controllers and processors in a specific sector'.
Privacy Shield framework. On 16 July 2020, the CJEU derailed EU–United States (US) personal data transfers, by invalidating the US adequacy decision, the keystone of the broader Privacy Shield framework. Contrary to the Commission, the Court held that the US does not provide for an adequate level of data protection on account of invasive US surveillance programmes. While companies may resort to alternative transfer mechanisms, the ruling exacerbated the legal uncertainties and costs associated with these tools. Most notably, businesses would need to compensate the shortfall in US data protection with additional legal, technical and/or organisational safeguards. After the US reformed its legal framework, the Commission adopted a new adequacy decision. Parliament identified shortcomings in the new US framework and called on the Commission to refrain from adopting the adequacy decision, but to no avail.
Data protection worldwide
The GDPR has been both praised and criticised for its standard‑setting role, and has been used as a model for law reform worldwide. Several countries and regions have taken inspiration from the GDPR when adopting their national legislation, while some multinationals have opted to use the GDPR as their global standard of operation. However, such legislation may still differ significantly from the GDPR in practice.
Role of the European Parliament
After supporting data protection law and policies in many different ways during its eighth term (2014‑2019), Parliament continued to play a vital role in its ninth term (2019‑2024).
Legislative procedures. Parliament has continually advocated a high level of data protection in legislative procedures concerning, for instance, additional GDPR procedural rules, measures to combat child sexual abuse (CSA) online, and the withdrawn proposal for an e-privacy regulation. It ensured the inclusion of privacy‑preserving safeguards in the CSA Regulation, temporarily exempting the scanning of internet‑based communications for online CSA from certain e‑privacy requirements.
Committee of inquiry. In response to what quickly became known as 'Europe's Watergate', Parliament set up a committee of inquiry to investigate the use of Pegasus and equivalent surveillance spyware (the PEGA committee). During its mandate, the PEGA committee interviewed over 215 interlocutors, commissioned studies, held hearings with experts and people who had been targeted, and organised fact‑finding visits to Cyprus, Greece, Hungary, Israel, Poland and Spain. In March 2023, PEGA adopted a 145‑page report with the results of its investigation; Parliament adopted its final recommendation in June 2023. Among other things, it identified country‑specific shortcomings and proposed EU standards for spyware use.
Scrutiny of draft adequacy decisions. Parliament followed the Commission negotiations on adequacy decisions actively, and objected to the Commission's draft adequacy decisions for the UK and the US. In two resolutions of February 2020 and June 2020, on the negotiations for a post‑Brexit EU–UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement, Parliament raised concerns regarding the UK level of data protection.
Approval of international agreements. Since the Lisbon Treaty, the conclusion of passenger name record (PNR) agreements requires Parliament's consent (Article 218(6a) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, TFEU). Parliament played a crucial role in the EU–Canada PNR agreement negotiations, where it sought a CJEU opinion pursuant Article 218(11) TFEU as opposed to giving consent. The CJEU found that the agreement interfered with fundamental rights to data protection and privacy, going beyond what could be justified in the fight against terrorism. This prompted the Council to launch new negotiations with Canada, which began in June 2018. On 4 October 2024, the Commission signed a new PNR agreement with Canada, which was approved by Parliament and the Council in 2025. Parliament will be involved similarly in any PNR agreement with Japan, Norway and Iceland.
Scrutiny of other Commission activities. In a resolution of March 2021 on the Commission's GDPR evaluation report, Parliament pointed out various gaps in implementation. In a November 2020 resolution, Parliament called on the Commission to launch infringement proceedings against Member States that did not repeal or align their data retention laws with CJEU case law, invalidating the Data Retention Directive (see Box 3 below). Furthermore, it emphasised that all initiatives announced in the data strategy should be consistent with the EU data protection and privacy acquis.
Hearings. Parliamentary committees have also held several hearings, concerning, for instance, AI and the data strategy, common values and fundamental rights issues in the European digital strategy, and the (then) pending data governance act.
Role of the Court of Justice of the EU
The CJEU has shaped the standards for data protection rights in the EU, emphasising the importance of firmly upholding data protection and privacy rights. One of the first landmark cases in this regard was the CJEU's 2014 ruling in Google Spain , where it affirmed the existence of a 'right to be forgotten' for EU citizens, namely that they have a right to request search engines such as Google to take down links to personal information when this information is 'inadequate, irrelevant or no longer relevant'. This right has since been enshrined in Article 17 of the GDPR. The CJEU provides a regularly updated digest of case law and a factsheet on data protection.
Box 3 – The data retention issue
The Data Retention Directive (2006/24/EC) was adopted in 2006 to create an EU‑wide scheme for the retention of personal data generated or processed by electronic communication services providers, in order to make it available when investigating and prosecuting crimes. It took several years before Member States transposed the directive into national law. In 2014, the CJEU struck down the directive in Digital Rights Ireland , on the basis that the 'mass, indiscriminate' storage of personal data permitted by the directive constituted a disproportionate interference with privacy rights. The CJEU followed this approach in Tele2 Sverige , clarifying however that 'targeted retention of traffic and location data for the purpose of fighting crimes' may be permitted if the retention is limited to what is strictly necessary. In La Quadrature du Net I (2020), it allowed preventive retention of all users' data for national security, as well as general retention of IP addresses for investigating serious crimes, public security threats, and national security. By 2022, the Court reaffirmed general IP address retention to combat serious crimes and, in La Quadrature du Net II (2024), extended this to lesser crimes such as online intellectual property violations. The Court deemed such retention less intrusive, citing safeguards in French law to mitigate privacy concerns. This most recent judgment sparked discussions among academics and pundits on the meaning and trajectory of the case law.
Member States did not respond to Tele2 Sverige in a uniform way, and despite further clarifications, the situation remains heterogeneous at the national level. Several Member States kept their domestic data retention regimes, while others annulled existing laws and replaced them with new ones, in an attempt to comply with the CJEU requirements of proportionality and targeted retention. Member States regard this patchwork of national laws as thwarting law enforcement cooperation; the situation has given rise to an as yet unresolved debate on the need to reintroduce EU‑wide legislation. (For the most recent – and possible future – developments, see the sub‑section on 'State surveillance'.)
Challenges for the future
Pending initiatives and future challenges in the area of data protection include rectifying GDPR enforcement deficits; balancing data needs of technology, data access for law enforcement, corporate tracking, and measures against CSA material with privacy and data protection requirements; and clarifying the interplay between data protection and data strategy regulations. Additionally, topics such as workplace surveillance ('bossware'), biometric recognition, emotion recognition, and mental privacy are increasingly discussed.
EU competitiveness and data needs of new technologies
As Europe faces mounting economic and geopolitical pressures, it is seeking to boost the bloc's competitiveness in accordance with its competitiveness agenda. Mario Draghi indicated in his report on the future of European competitiveness that reducing compliance burdens for small mid‑cap companies (SMCs) and boosting AI development would contribute to Europe's competitiveness. Consequently, the Commission launched stakeholder reflections on the ʹsimplificationʹ of the EU digital acquis, including data protection and privacy rules.
Given that AI is widely considered a driver of EU competitiveness, but that its characteristics are in tension with current data protection rules, disputes arise as to the appropriate level of stringency, efficiency and clarity of EU data protection rules. The Commission has indicated that a lack of legal certainty, as well as inefficient rules whose objectives could be achieved through simpler measures, hamper EU competitiveness. At the same time, stakeholders and experts debate how strict data protection rules for AI should be, and how they should be applied and enforced. While under‑regulation risks exposing data subjects to unwarranted data protection risks and eroding trust in new technologies, over‑regulation may contribute to stifling innovation and undermining EU competitiveness. Article 8 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights stipulates that data processing may not interfere disproportionately with the fundamental right to data protection.
Possible ways forward
Adopt non‑legislative clarifications. The Council, the Fundamental Rights Agency (FRA) and Parliament have called on the Commission to clarify how the GDPR applies to new technologies such as AI. The EDPS Tech Dispatches provide a preliminary assessment, and the EDPB announced plans to release guidelines on the use of new technologies and on the cross‑regulatory landscape. The recent EDPB opinion on the processing of personal data by AI models excludes key issues such as processing of special categories of data, automated decisionmaking, and data protection impact assessments.
Legislative reforms. In its proposal for a 'digital omnibus' (or 'data omnibus'), the Commission proposes ʹsimplifyingʹ data protection requirements. Most notably, it suggests redefining personal data in way that would clearly limit the material scope of the GDPR and introducing new legal bases for developing and using AI.2 Civil society organisations, such as NOYB and European Digital Rights (EDRi), as well as experts, argue that this amendment fails to reflect the broader definition of personal data under CJEU case law, question the desirability of adding legal bases for data processing in the AI context, and challenge whether this would increase EU competitiveness. The Commission is careful to emphasise that it is primarily proposing technical and cost‑cutting amendments that would achieve the existing regulatory objectives. By contrast, civil society organisation NOYB argues that the data protection amendments contained in the digital omnibus proposal would weaken existing safeguards rather than provide technical clarifications.
To help small and medium‑sized enterprises (SMEs) scale up, and to relax compliance burdens on SMCs, the Commission tabled a separate proposal, the Omnibus IV package, to simplify rules and reduce bureaucracy for SMCs. Article 1 suggests relaxing the GDPR compliance burdens by extending the existing derogation from the obligation to maintain records of processing activities – currently applicable to organisations with fewer than 250 employees – to cover SMCs also. Members of the European Parliament (MEPs) and civil society organisations have expressed support for reducing burdens on SMEs.
Apply the new AI Act. The AI Act can be seen as mitigating the risks of a specific data‑driven technology. In the previous parliamentary term, the co‑legislators adopted the AI Act incorporating a phased application timeline. Meanwhile, the Commission has proposed amendments, including a delay for applying high‑risk AI obligations and softening AI literacy obligations.
Institutional guidance. The newly established European AI Office supports the development and use of trustworthy AI, while protecting against AI risks. In line with stakeholder calls for additional guidance, the EDPB has adopted guidance on what constitutes an 'unfounded or excessive data subjects' request' and held a public consultation on how to make GDPR compliance easy for organisations, announcing that it intends to develop a series of ready‑to‑use templates.
Corporate surveillance
To achieve economic objectives and enhance user experience, many companies personalise products, processes and advertisements by approximating and predicting customer attributes and behaviours through profiling and data analysis. Companies collect the necessary input data for these operations through various methods. In addition to requesting information or observing offline behaviour, they collect data by logging and tracking user activities; by scraping, sharing and trading data; and by merging or acquiring companies. Researchers have identified multiple fields of application that rely on tracking and profiling; these include marketing; customer analytics; credit scoring and personal finance; fraud prevention and risk management; employee monitoring, hiring and workforce analytics; insurance; healthcare; and e‑learning. With the deployment of smart applications and machines, the concerns over individuals' dignity, autonomy and privacy will further increase. There is growing concern over the industry developing capabilities to recognise cognitive and affective states.
Additionally, some communication companies voluntarily scan internet‑based communications for child sexual abuse material in order to report and remove it (often referred to as ʹchat control 1.0ʹ). A temporary derogation from the e‑Privacy Directive – adopted in 2021 and now pending extension – shields qualified communications services from liability under the e‑Privacy Directive; however, the permissibility of certain techniques and their deployment under the GDPR remains unsettled.
Possible ways forward
Legislative harmonisation. Reportedly, Ursula von der Leyen highlighted online advertising as a priority when meeting European Parliament political groups ahead of her re‑election as President of the European Commission. Aspects of digital advertising could be tackled by a digital fairness act and, possibly, a digital advertising act.
Progress has been made on examining the digital advertising market and framework, with the Commission externalising a first study concluding that the current framework is unsustainable, and launching further work on gaps in the applicable regulatory regime. Additionally, the Commission's 2024 digital fairness check identified gaps in consumer protection regarding commercial personalisation, including the personalisation of advertising, and its 2025 call for evidence signalled that it would consider policy options to better protect consumers with respect to problematic personalisation practices. By contrast, civil society organisation criticise the Commission's plan to redefine personal data under the digital omnibus, because it could permit commercial surveillance and political microtargeting, contradicting citizensʹ expectations3 and, arguably, CJEU case law.
The Commission proposal for permanent rules to combat child sexual abuse, intended to replace the temporary regulation, has divided stakeholders. Unlike the interim regulation, the new proposal would, among other things, (i) follow a system of risk mitigation obligations and duties to comply with detection orders; (ii) act as a legal basis under the GDPR; and (iii) apply to hosting services. While supported by some child protection organisations and industry actors, it has faced strong opposition from 133 civil society groups and over 300 security researchers and academics.4 The joint opinion of the EDPB and EDPS is largely critical.
Enforcement of new and existing rules. A wide range of EU laws apply to digital advertising. Enforcement action brought by individuals and NGOs have helped clarify that data processing for behavioural advertising requires consent as a legal basis. Complainants from Belgium and third countries successfully challenged a now defunct industry standard for collecting consent for behavioural targeting using real‑time bidding methods. Meanwhile, NOYB filed complaints against ʹforced consentʹ, including ʹconsent or payʹ, practices in 2018, 2021 and 2023. If successful, these would force social media platforms to rethink their consent and/or advertising model. In 2023, the Society for Civil Rights and an individual Facebook user filed a lawsuit against Meta's practice of scanning private messages sent via the Facebook Messenger.
Self‑ and co‑regulation. Under Article 46 of the Digital Services Act (DSA), the Commission is to encourage and facilitate the creation of voluntary codes of conduct for the advertising sector.
Institutional guidance. In 2024, the EDPB issued guidelines indicating that it would not be possible for large platforms to comply with the requirements for valid consent if they prompt users with a binary choice between consenting to processing of personal data for behavioural advertising purposes and paying a fee. Following this interpretation, information society services would be required to reassess their consent mechanisms and advertising models. Meta has brought legal proceedings challenging the opinion, which remain pending on appeal. The EDPB could adopt additional guidelines for other market actors. The Commission has published guidelines on AI practices prohibited under the AI Act, including on manipulative AI systems, and on the protection of minors under the DSA; it could issue further guidance on the assessment of unfair and exploitative advertising under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive and the DSA, and on proportionate measures to detect child sexual abuse material online under the GDPR, LED, and the e‑Privacy Directive.
State surveillance
Digitalisation has reshaped criminal activity, transformed the nature of harms, and created new criminal opportunities, sparking debate on the need to update law enforcement and judicial authorities' investigative measures and practices. These authorities report growing technical, organisational and legal obstacles in obtaining timely access to electronic evidence and intelligence. The Commission notes that fragmentation and uneven requirements across the EU pose additional obstacles for accessing data. By contrast, the Pegasus scandal, involving the alleged abuse of commercial spyware by various EU and non‑EU governments against journalists, politicians, lawyers and civil society actors, underlines the need for strict safeguards when authorities use intrusive investigative tools. Article 8 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights stipulates that investigative measures may not interfere disproportionately with data protection rights. EU lawmakers will have to ensure appropriate safeguards for both investigation subjects and incidentally affected persons.
Possible ways forward
Legislative harmonisation. The Council has repeatedly called for5 the adoption of an EU‑level data retention framework. On 24 June 2025, the European Commission presented a roadmap for lawful and effective access to data for law enforcement setting out the way forward to ensure law enforcement authorities in the EU have effective access to data, and announced plans to review and, as necessary, update the EU's data retention rules. Meanwhile, the Commission has conducted a call for evidence and a public consultation in preparation of an impact assessment on data retention. Digital rights advocacy organisations, led by EDRi, oppose a new EU data retention scheme and favour launching infringement proceedings.
In its final recommendation following its investigations of the (Pegasus) spyware scandal, Parliament called on the Commission to table draft laws based on its recommendations, notably regulating EU spyware surveillance standards and the placing of spyware on the market. However, repeatedly emphasising protections under Article 4 of the European Media Freedom Act and a lack of competence, the Commission refrained from developing such a legislative initiative.
Implementation and enforcement of EU legal framework. In its November 2020 resolution, Parliament called on the Commission to initiate infringement proceedings against Member States that had failed to repeal national transposition acts of the annulled Data Retention Directive. In a similar vein, victims of spyware surveillance had urged the Commission to investigate alleged abuses by Member States.
Targets of spyware surveillance are pursuing legal actions against Member States before the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). So far, cases against Greece, Hungary and Poland have reached the ECtHR, but only the Greek Koukakis case ended in a dismissal for breach of confidence.
Facilitate and coordinate cooperation. In its June 2025 roadmap, the Commission announced that it plans to take various measures to improve access to data for law enforcement by facilitating and coordinating cross‑country cooperation.
Institutional guidance. In its roadmap, the Commission also announced clear guidelines for the use of AI (for effectively analysing evidence) in law enforcement. The Commission appears reluctant to publish the communication setting out the boundaries for spyware, which it had begun working on, and which had reportedly reached the draft stage in 2024. Instead, the Venice Commission issued a report on spyware standards in December 2024.
GDPR enforcement deficits
Since the GDPR became applicable in May 2018, Parliament and civil society organisations have been flagging up deficits in its enforcement, and pushing for better implementation. Large technology companies are said to apply the letter but not the spirit of the law, and some regionally competent SAs are said to endorse or shield such behaviour. Since the GDPR's entry into force, FRA, Parliament's Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs (LIBE), the EDPB, the Multistakeholder Expert Group and the Council have alerted the Commission of concerns regarding resource constraints. To remedy enforcement deficits, the co‑legislators adopted new GDPR procedural rules for cross-border cases set to apply as of 2 April 2027; DPAs continue to impose substantial fines reaching as high as €1.2 billion; and the European Commission has urged Member States to ensure that DPAs are adequately resourced, or they risk facing infringement procedures, while itself funding projects addressing personal data protection challenges.
Endnotes
Disclaimer
This document is prepared for, and addressed to, the Members and staff of the European Parliament as background material to assist them in their parliamentary work. The content of the document is the sole responsibility of its author(s) and any opinions expressed herein should not be taken to represent an official position of the Parliament.
