EU emissions trading system (2026 revision)
Key findings
The impact assessment (IA) provides a qualitative and quantitative analysis to underpin the revision of the EU emissions trading system (ETS) package. Given the size and the complexity of the package, this appraisal focuses on its most relevant aspects. The main weakness of this IA is that the information is disorganised and scattered, and it fails to address several important aspects. The IA does not explain the problem or address the objectives of all three proposals; it does so only for the EU ETS Directive and the market stability reserve, as well as for the Industrial Decarbonisation Bank, a new funding instrument under the EU ETS Directive. The policy measures are, in general, explained in detail. However, some key information is missing, such as the assessment of including emissions from municipal waste incineration in the scope. The environmental impacts are mostly focused on climate, the social impacts analyse consequences on employment, while economic impacts cover several aspects with a particular focus on small and medium‑sized enterprises. The IA does not provide key performance indicators that would enable regular assessment of progress towards the initiatives' objectives. Many stakeholders expressed their views in the public consultation, and their views have been integrated into the IA. However, some recommendations proposed by the Regulatory Scrutiny Board have not been addressed properly. The Commission's proposals follow the preferred policy option identified in the IA to a great extent.
Purpose statement (this title will not be shown in final layout)
This briefing provides an initial analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of the European Commission's impact assessment (IA) accompanying the package of three proposals relating to the emissions trading system (ETS), submitted on 17 July 2026: (i) the proposal for a directive amending Directive 2003/87/EC and Decision (EU) 2015/1814 as regards driving competitiveness and cost‑effective decarbonisation; (ii) the proposal for a regulation amending Directive 2003/87/EC as regards revised benchmark values for the heat and fuel benchmarks for the period from 2026 to 2030; and (iii) the proposal for a regulation amending Regulations (EU) 2015/757 and 2023/1805 to simplify and streamline monitoring, reporting and verification and to align with revisions of the EU emissions trading system. This briefing, prepared for the Committee on the Environment, Climate and Food Safety (ENVI committee), analyses whether the principal criteria laid down in the Commission's own Better Regulation Guidelines (BRG), as well as additional factors identified by the Parliament in its Impact Assessment Handbook, appear to be met by the IA. It does not attempt to deal with the substance of the proposal, which will be covered in a separate briefing.
Background
The Directive establishing a scheme for greenhouse gas emission allowance trading (EU ETS Directive), adopted in 2003, is the world's first international emissions trading system. It evolved through several trading phases, progressively aligning with international commitments, such as the Kyoto Protocol and the Paris Agreement, as well as EU climate legislation. The directive covers greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from electricity and heat generation, industrial manufacturing, aviation, and maritime transport emissions. Since 2024, it covers the monitoring of GHG emissions from the incineration of municipal waste, while not required to pay for the GHGs emitted.1 The 2026 EU ETS revision is a package of three interlinked proposals.2 The proposal for a directive amending the EU ETS Directive and the Market Stability Reserve (MSR) Decision claims to align the system with the Union's 2040 emissions reduction target of net 90 % compared with 1990 levels, and to increase the EU's competitiveness and resilience. The proposal for a regulation amending the EU ETS Directive as regards revised benchmark values for the heat and fuel benchmarks fulfils the commitment to increase free allocation levels determined by the heat and fuel benchmarks up to 2030 under Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/1412. The proposal to amend the Regulation on the monitoring, reporting and verification of carbon dioxide emissions from maritime transport (MRV) and the Regulation on the use of renewable and low-carbon fuels in maritime transport (FuelEU Maritime) simplifies monitoring, reporting and verification for operators complying with the MRV and FuelEU Maritime obligations, and extends the scope of the MRV.
Problem definition
The impact assessment (IA) insufficiently addresses the problems and their drivers. The analysis of such complex set of initiatives should have been elaborated more deeply. The explanation and the analysis of problems is scattered over several different parts of the IA, making it difficult to get a clear and concise overview of all problems. Because of this structure, there is also much unnecessary repetition, adding to the perplexity. The IA is presented as addressing all three ETS proposals, yet its content suggests otherwise.
After careful consideration of all IA elements, it appears that the IA analyses the problems and their drivers for two elements of the proposals: the ETS in general (Part 1, pp. 9‑12, and Part 2, pp. 98‑102), and the specific Industrial Decarbonisation Bank (IDB) element (Part 3, pp. 159‑163). While the IA does not specifically explain whether the general ETS problem is common to all three proposals, the explanation of the drivers and sub‑drivers makes it possible to conclude that it is linked mainly to the ETS Directive and MSR proposal. Following this assumption, it appears that there is no targeted problem definition, nor are there drivers for the ETS benchmarks,the MRV and the FuelEU Maritime regulations. No explanation is provided as to why there is a dedicated analysis regarding the IDB as a specific provision under the EU ETS proposal.
The problem tree (IA, Part 1, p. 10) is cumbersome and difficult to understand. It illustrates the problems, their drivers and sub‑drivers, and links them with the general and specific objectives. It also creates a link with 11 specific problems (P): P1: increase or redirect funding; P2: treatment of carbon reuse; P3: free allocation; P4: evasion in maritime transport; P5: EU ETS scope expansion to cover waste management emissions; P6: scope of aviation; P7: scope of maritime; P8: 20 megawatts (MW) thermal input threshold; P9: inclusion of carbon removals; P10: cap trajectory adjustments; P11: MSR design. The IA does not explain those 11 specific problems, and for most of them, the problem tree is the only place where they have been explicitly mentioned as an identified problem. This entire section should have been explained more effectively, in particular the interlinkages between the specific objectives and the specific problems.
The analysis of the problems relies on the findings of the evaluation report (IA, Part 5, Annex 15). The report concludes that the EU ETS is well aligned with the broader EU climate policies, and suggests that the ETS sectors contributed significantly to the achievement of the 2030 emissions reduction targets. However, the evaluation also indicated several elements in need of improvement that have been addressed in these Commission proposals, such as carbon leakage, incentives for investments in decarbonisation, the monitoring, reporting, verification and accreditation (MRVA) system, and the security measures for the Union Registry.
The IA identifies two key problems that the ETS Directive and MSR proposal aims to address (see Table 1):
-
General problem 1 (GP1): Risk of not contributing cost‑effectively to the EU emissions reduction target in line with EU climate targets, and addressing the EU ETS' share of international emissions. According to the IA, this risk is due to several reasons, such as a misalignment of the EU ETS cap trajectory, market failures, lack of business case and insufficient investments in decarbonisation of certain sectors, and the incoherence between the EU ETS and global measures.
-
General problem 2 (GP2): Risk of market inefficiencies, such as trading frictions or price volatility, due to the shrinking of the European carbon market.
| Drivers (D) and sub‑drivers (SD) | GP1: Risk of not contributing cost‑effectively to the EU emissions reduction target, and addressing the EU ETS' share of international emissions | GP2: Risk of market inefficiencies |
|---|---|---|
| D1 | Residual emissions are inconsistent with EU ETS cap trajectory | ‑ |
| SD1.1 | CO2 generation is currently unavoidable for certain activities (P9, P10) | ‑ |
| SD1.2 | Insufficient financing for innovation, scale‑up and roll‑out of decarbonisation technologies and clean fuels (P1) | ‑ |
| SD1.3 | Unlevel playing field for carbon capture and utilisation (CCU) and double counting of emissions (P2) | ‑ |
| D2 | Lack of internalisation of the climate impact (insufficient carbon price signal) | ‑ |
| SD2.1 | Free allocation reduces carbon price incentives; indirect carbon cost in electricity hinders industrial electrification (P3) | ‑ |
| SD2.2 | Current regulations exempt small installations under 20 MW (P8) | ‑ |
| SD2.3 | Risk of evasion in maritime sector (P4) | ‑ |
| SD2.4 | Limited scope of aviation and maritime (P6, P7, P8) | ‑ |
| SD2.5 | No comprehensive coverage of waste emissions (P5) | ‑ |
| D3 | International carbon pricing measures in transport | ‑ |
| SD3.1 | Possible inadequate implementation of Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation (CORSIA) by third countries (P6) | ‑ |
| SD3.2 | Potential lack of coherence between ETS implementation and the implementation of possible International Maritime Organization (IMO) mid‑term measures in the future (P7)3 | ‑ |
| D4 | Decreasing market size | Decreasing market size |
| SD4.1 | ‑ | Intrinsic functioning of the EU ETS can lead to market failure (P10, P11) |
Subsidiary / proportionality
The IA includes only a small section on subsidiarity (Part 1, p. 13), while the Subsidiarity Grid offers more insight into subsidiarity and proportionality. The explanatory memorandums briefly touch on subsidiarity and proportionality, as well. The IA explained and justified the EU added value of the proposal well (Part 5, pp. 76‑79). All these documents highlight that EU‑level action is needed because of the trans‑boundary nature of climate change. The Subsidiarity Grid emphasises that achieving Union's climate goals requires Union‑wide cost‑efficient emissions reductions and increased resources, something that could not be assured without coordinated EU action. It explains that an EU‑wide approach is crucial to ensuring the proper functioning of the single market, securing a level playing field, creating economies of scale, and preserving environmental integrity. It also prevents 'environmental dumping' between the Members States, where Member States favour less rigorous climate measures to support their own economies at the expense of internal market functioning and the achievement of climate action objectives. In addition, the explanatory memorandum accompanying the Commission proposal (p. 10) mentions that 'implementing a similar measure nationally would result in smaller, fragmented carbon markets, risking distortions of competition and likely leading to higher overall abatement costs. The same logic holds for extending carbon pricing to cover new sectors'. Article 192(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) is the legal basis for the three interlinked proposals. The Subsidiarity Grid and the explanatory memorandums confirm that the proposals comply with the proportionality principle, since they do not go beyond what is needed to achieve the Union's climate goals.
The choice of instruments is justified considering those principles. A directive is the most appropriate legal instrument to amend the existing ETS Directive. A regulation amending the ETS Directive regarding the update of the benchmark values for heat and fuel benchmarks appears appropriate, as it does not require transposition by Member States, and the update is implemented directly by the Commission. Because of its legal form, a regulation is the most appropriate legal instrument to amend the MRV and FuelEU Maritime regulations.
No reasoned opinions were issued by the national parliaments scrutinising the proposals at the time of writing (subsidiarity deadlines have not yet been published).
Objectives of the initiative
The main objective of the EU ETS is to contribute to the EU economy's GHG emissions reduction, including its share of global emissions, to achieve the intermediate 2040 climate target, and eventually the climate neutrality objective by 2050. The IA breaks down this main objective into several general objectives (GOs) of the ETS Directive and MSR, corresponding to each of the two main problems. It then develops further several specific objectives (SOs). SOs have not been set for all the key elements of the proposals. For instance, there are no SOs for the emissions from the waste sector (see Table 2).
| Problem | Problem 1 | Problem 2 | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| General objectives | GO1.1: Incentivising emissions reductions | GO1.2: Reaching a pre‑set emissions reduction target for 2040 | GO1.3: Ensuring effectiveness of EU climate action on international transport | GO2.1: Ensuring efficient market functioning |
| Specific objectives | SO1.1.1: Enable investments in decarbonisation technologies | SO1.2.1: Consider if carbon removals can be integrated into the ETS | SO1.3.1: Ensure effective action on EU's fair share of aviation emissions | SO2.1.1: Increase size of the market until 2040 |
| SO1.1.2: Ensure full carbon price signal is applied to the emissions' sources, which are currently not in the scope of the EU ETS | SO1.2.2: Adjust the ETS cap in line with the climate target for 2040 | SO1.3.2: Preserve the effectiveness of the implementation of the EU ETS extension to maritime transport, and ensure regulatory efficiency of the EU ETS on maritime transport and IMO measures | SO2.1.2: Adjust MSR parameters to ensure a proper supply‑demand balance | |
| SO1.1.3: Address the risk of carbon leakage | ||||
This section of the IA is lacking adequate level of detail. It is confusing to extract the relevant information, as the IA splits the explanation of the objectives into two parts (Part 1, pp. 13‑14, and Part 2, pp 102‑105), with much duplication and little new information. Furthermore, the IA links the objectives solely to EU ETS and MSR, without any mention of the objectives relating to the other two proposals on the ETS benchmarks and the MRV and FuelEU Maritime. For example, one of the amendments to the MRV Regulation is the extension of the scope to certain categories of ships, which is a significant change, yet the IA does not address this objective, nor does it link it to any of the problems identified. It does, however, provide different policy options and consequences for maritime (Annex 11, pp. 260‑314). The IA offers an analysis of the objectives specifically for the IDB (Part 3, Annex 9, pp. 163‑164), although without explaining the criteria for singling out this specific provision under the ETS proposal.
The objectives do not fully comply with the ' SMART ' criteria (specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time‑bound), as recommended by Better Regulation Toolbox (BRT) Tool #15. Several objectives, such as the one on MRV, are entirely missing. The IA does not mention any key performance indicators (KPI) for these objectives, so it is unclear how they will be measured and whether they are bound to the same 2040 timeline.
The IA expects progress towards eight United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): good health and wellbeing (SDG 3); affordable and clean energy (SDG 7); decent work and economic growth (SDG 8); industry, innovation and infrastructure (SDG 9); sustainable cities and communities (SDG 11); responsible consumption and productions (SDG 12); climate action (SDG 13); and life below water (SDG 14) (Part 2, pp. 51‑53).
Range of options considered
The IA indicates that the baseline of this IA reflects the ETS legislative framework (Directive 2023/959) and the overall 2030 climate package as legislated before the Commission proposal. The specification of the baseline considers several key developments relating to the EU ETS – such as the linear reduction factor, cap, MSR, scope, sustainable aviation fuels, and allowances – and explains the exceptions linked to the free allocation for sectors not covered by the carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM), and the financial instruments. It also offers specific baseline analysis for the IDB and aviation. The IA does not explain the baseline relating to the ETS heat and fuel benchmarks proposal and the amendments to the MRV and FuelEU Maritime proposal.
The IA identifies three policy options (POs) that differ in the scale of modification of the ETS system as it is, with each option gradually increasing the degree of change. It provides a useful overview of both the POs and the policy measures (PMs) under them relating to the proposal on the EU ETS and MSR and the MRV (Part 1, pp. 17‑21). No specific measure relates to the ETS heat and fuel benchmarks. In total, 69 measures have been developed and assessed, out of which seven have been discarded following the assessment, and they are mostly well justified. The IA also explains several other measures well that have been discarded at an early stage (carbon removals, MSR and waste).
The a nalysis of POs and PMs is split over several parts of the IA, making it challenging to get a complete, clear and detailed picture of all the measures and of the rationale behind grouping the measures into different options. Owing to a high degree of dispersed information, it is difficult to extract some key conclusions. For instance, it is unclear why the IA concluded that the CAP2 measure should be included in the preferred option if CAP4 is actually contributing with the highest emissions reductions. The IA states that 'no single option is preferred', yet does not explain well why there is no preference. The IA would have benefited from a correlation table linking all elements of the IA analysis scattered around different parts of the IA.
The IA provides a sufficient level of detail for most of the policy measures. However, several measures have either not been developed enough (Modernisation Fund) or lack explanation for certain elements. For example, the revised 2023 EU ETS Directive required a report on a feasibility of the inclusion of GHG emissions from municipal waste incineration (MWI) in the EU ETS from 2028 (Article 30(7)). The IA did not specify the proposed year for inclusion, although it did use modelling of the EU ETS cap extension for the inclusion of emissions from MWI for 2030 (Part 4, p. 76), and the proposal requires inclusion as of 2031. A comparison of costs and benefits, as well as an analysis of environmental, social and economic impacts of different timings of the MWI inclusion, would have been beneficial. In addition, a potential risk of waste exports to third countries if the emissions from the MWI are included in the EU ETS was insufficiently addressed.
The IA compares the effectiveness, efficiency and coherence of the POs (Part 1, pp. 85‑97). Their effectiveness was assessed from strongly negative to strongly positive. Efficiency was compared based on the expected benefits versus the expected costs. Finally, the IA compared how coherent POs are with other EU policies.4 Based on those criteria, the IA concluded that the preferred policy option is PO2: Aligning ambition and extending scope and corresponding incentives. PO2 includes 22 PMs relating to 10 elements of the proposals: cap adjustment, carbon removals, MSR, IDB, Modernisation Fund (MF), aviation, maritime, stationary installations, waste, and carbon capture and utilisation (CCU). The IA does not compare the POs in terms of subsidiarity and proportionality. The option of changing nothing is not adequately explained.
Assessment of impacts
In conformity with BRT Tool #18, the IA assesses (qualitatively and quantitatively) all three options for their economic, social and environmental impact. The main report contains a lengthy section on the impacts of the measures relating to cap, removals, MSR, instruments to support investments, aviation, maritime, carbon leakage, waste, and CCU (Part 1, pp. 22‑85). The annexes provide a detailed analysis for removals, MSR, aviation, maritime, carbon leakage, 20 MW threshold, waste, and non‑permanent CCU (Parts 3 and 4).
The aim of the IA section on environmental impacts from the main report (Part 1, pp. 22‑45) is to assess the impacts of measures from the climate impacts perspective, i.e. how the ETS measures are contributing to the achievement of the EU's 2040 climate targets for gross and net emissions. The climate impacts assessed are GHG emissions reduction, carbon leakage and emissions leakage avoidance.5 However, this part of the IA focuses more on re‑explaining and comparing the measures under different options, rather than clearly describing their climate impacts. This section lacks systematic quantification of GHG emissions reduction.
The IA also includes a section 'Other environmental impacts (e.g. biodiversity and pollution)' (Part 1, pp. 43‑45). The IA briefly mentions positive impacts on air quality, circular economy, waste prevention, recycling and use. It also addresses the risk of diversion of waste to landfills linked to policy measures on waste. However, the analysis is insufficient, both in terms of the sectors that were assessed and of the information provided. For instance, an assessment of the aviation sector provides only a table of total externalities costs – which would be more suitable for the section on economic impacts – instead of providing data on air pollution. Despite the title, the impacts on biodiversity have not been assessed but are only mentioned in relation to the removals.
The annexes supplementing the main report provide insufficient information about the environmental impacts, and often unsubstantiated claims. For example, a section on environmental impacts of maritime transport measures (Part 3, p. 270) states that they could lead to an increased use of sustainable maritime fuels, or GHG emissions reductions in the range of between 1.7 and 9 million tonnes of CO2 (MtCO2) by 2035, without however providing a source for these claims.
The analysis of the social impacts covers impacts on employment and skills, and on fundamental rights. The IA concludes that the carbon removal measures would lead to an increase in employment opportunities in the EU's removal industry. Some positive employment impacts are expected in the aviation sector, while the maritime sector could face a minor decrease of employment relating to smaller vessels. The carbon leakage measures show insignificant changes to the employment level, while the continuation of indirect carbon cost (ICC) compensation would have a positive impact through the protection against carbon leakage and the support for electrification and industrial processes. The waste sector is expected to see an increase in employment relating to circular economy jobs. IDB could have a positive impact on employment in all sectors of the economy. The IA concluded that none of the policy options would have a negative impact on fundamental rights. It did not specify any positive impacts, apart from an impact on environmental protection in line with Article 37 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union.
The IA analyses a wide range of economic impacts. The measures are assessed mainly in terms of the same type of impacts: cost of compliance; administrative effort for the private sector; sectoral competitiveness; trade and investment flows; public authorities; small and medium‑sized enterprises (SMEs); and the impacts on the functioning of the internal market. Given the specificity of measures, the analysis is sometimes focusing on different aspects. For instance, for the removals, the conduct of business is linked to EU ETS compliance costs, market dynamics and transaction costs, which is not the case for all elements of the proposals. On the other hand, the MSR analysis includes additional aspects such as the liquidity in the EU ETS and price volatility. Those adjustments in the analysis of economic impacts are both reasonable and adequately used. The analysis is particularly detailed for the aviation sector, and includes an assessment of impacts of CORSIA, short‑haul flights, outermost regions, and private and business jets inclusion.
The IA explains that the assessment is focused on the cost analysis for businesses and their competitiveness. There is also a section on the impacts on public authorities, which shows a benefit for them arising from the revenue of the EU ETS allowance auction. The IA provides a quantitative assessment of macroeconomic impacts of measures; however, some data in this section come from 'own calculations', and it is therefore unclear what their source is and if the data are reliable.
SMEs / Competitiveness
The IA paid special attention to the impacts on SMEs. The IA includes an 'SME test' (Part 2, pp. 92‑96). In line with the scope of the EU ETS Directive, which keeps the 20 MW threshold exempted from the EU ETS, most of the EU ETS installations are operated by the large companies; SMEs would thus not be significantly impacted. In addition, small emitters have an option to opt‑out. There are also provisions simplifying the operations of SMEs, while micro enterprises remain largely out of scope. The maritime transport sector will face bigger impacts due to the extension of the scope of ETS to smaller vessels. The IA identified as the main challenges the SMEs' more limited capacity to absorb additional administrative costs, and their limited ability to access financing for investments in decarbonisation technologies.
The IA concluded that predictable carbon pricing and available innovation funding would reduce the negative impact on competitiveness. The benefits and costs of the preferred option were analysed (Part 2, pp. 35‑48) but not always quantified. The initiative is included in the SME filter.6
Simplification, burden reduction and other regulatory implications
As part of the REFIT programme, the evaluation report assessed the potential for simplification and burden reduction, relying on the results of the open public consultations. The report identified several areas in need of simplification, such as small installations, procedures for competent authorities and MRV, and highlighted a need for greater harmonisation and streamlining with other EU environmental legislation. It also presented tables with information on the savings from simplification and burden reduction already achieved by the EU ETS, and potential simplification and burden reduction relating to the conditionality for free allocation and MSR (Part 5, Appendix IV, pp. 243‑245).
The proposals introduce targeted simplifications aimed at eliminating administrative burden for operators, reducing administrative compliance costs, and minimising existing duplications. Those provisions relate mainly to the MRV maritime, but also to the small operators in the aviation sector. The IA presents a compilation of the new administrative burdens, as well as those that have been removed, in a 'one in, one out' table (Part 2, pp. 49‑50).
Monitoring and evaluation
The IA does not provide key performance indicators (KPIs) that would enable regular assessment of the progress towards the initiatives' objectives. Several articles under the EU ETS Directive set provisions regarding monitoring and evaluation of the ETS for the Commission and the Member States. Article 10(5) mandates the Commission to prepare yearly report on the functioning of the carbon market and on other relevant climate and energy policies. Article 21 requires Member States to report on the allocation of allowances, operation of the Union Registry, MRVA, and compliance. Several articles in the EU ETS Directive include provisions on the review (Articles 3gg, 28b, 30, 30i), as does Article 30 of the FuelEU Maritime Regulation. The Commission will maintain regular contacts with stakeholders through Climate Change Expert Group (CCEG) meetings, the ETS Compliance Forum and the Technical Working Group on ETS MRVA.
Stakeholder consultation
The IA provides sufficient information about the consultation activities. The Commission organised an open public consultation on EU ETS, which was open for 12 weeks, in line with BRT Tool #51. In addition, several other consultation activities relating to all three EU ETS proposals took place; these are detailed in Table 3. Several stakeholders submitted their position papers. The IA explains the process of consultation, yet does not provide a summary of the consultation results in terms of participants' responses. It would have been easier to understand the stakeholder views if the information had been presented in tables or charts instead of text form.
According to the IA, private sector respondents (companies, businesses and business associations) were the most active (76 % of responses). Other stakeholders were non‑governmental organisations (NGOs), public authorities, EU citizens, environmental organisations, academic or research institutions, and trade unions. Their responses were analysed and grouped into categories corresponding to the specific elements of the EU ETS proposals. The most frequent sectors represented were the waste management and energy sectors. Stakeholders' views have been systematically integrated into the description of PMs. It appears that no option enjoying broad support among stakeholders was ruled out.
| Consultation type | Problem concerned | Dates | Total replies received |
|---|---|---|---|
| Call for evidence | EU ETS for maritime, aviation and stationary installations, and market stability reserve | 14 April – 8 July 2025 | 377 |
| Open public consultation | EU ETS for maritime, aviation and stationary installations, and market stability reserve | 15 April – 8 July 2025 | 540 |
| Call for evidence | Innovation Fund | 14 April – 8 July 2025 | 97 |
| Open public consultation | Innovation Fund | 15 April – 8 July 2025 | 93 |
| Call for evidence | Modernisation Fund | 14 April – 26 May 2025 | 43 |
| Joint meeting | European Sustainable Shipping Forum sub‑group on the implementation of MRV and ETS Maritime (ESSF) and CCEG Maritime | 18 June 2024 | N/A |
| Consultation with the expert group | Free allocation on the benchmark values for the period 2026‑2030 | 5 November 2025, 15 December 2025 and 21 January 2026 | N/A |
| Workshop | EU ETS – stationary installations | 29 January 2026 | >50 |
| High‑level stakeholder roundtable | Review of the EU ETS | 12 May 2026 | <60 |
| Public feedback | Update of ETS benchmark values for 2026‑2030 | 11 May – 8 June 2026 | 442 |
| Expert group meeting with Member States | Update of ETS benchmark values for 2026‑2030 | 3 June 2026 | N/A |
| Expert group meeting with Member States and industry representatives | Update of ETS benchmark values for 2026‑2030 | 3 June 2026 | N/A |
Supporting data and analytical methods used
A brief section in the IA on 'Evidence, sources and quality' (Part 2, p. 8) informs that this IA builds on the evidence gathered in the IAs for the previous 2023 EU ETS revision, and the 2040 climate target proposal. It uses emissions data from the implementation of the EU monitoring, reporting and verification systems. The IA also relies on several support contracts; however, this section does not provide any information about them. Many parts of the IA are based on data and evidence from 'forthcoming' studies, such as the 'Aviation support study' or the 'Support for the 2026 review of the ETS directive for maritime', thereby reducing transparency and accessibility to the sources. It is unclear whether the studies are not publicly available or whether they have not been finalised. The assessment of impacts often fails to provide sources for the claims.
The revised 2023 EU ETS Directive mandated the Commission to prepare a report by 31 July 2026 covering several important elements7 that have been addressed in the proposed initiatives. It appears that this report has not been prepared. Instead, the assessment of some elements of the requested report have been integrated into this IA, albeit often only partially. Some other elements are being addressed in the above‑mentioned separate support studies that are currently not publicly available. The absence of the evidence presented in those studies makes it difficult to assess the IA's quality.
The IA analysis also relies on the use of three European Commission Joint Research Centre (JRC) models, which were sufficiently explained. JRC-GEM-E3 was used for GHG emissions; PRIMES for the analysis of climate and energy policies; and POTEnCIA for cap setting and carbon removals. In addition, the POLES-Enerdata model was used for MSR. The assumptions and scenarios are presented in detail (Part 2, pp. 55‑85).
Follow‑up to Commission Regulatory Scrutiny Board opinion
The Regulatory Scrutiny Board (RSB) issued a positive opinion with reservations on 17 April 2026. The opinion covered the IA and the evaluation of the EU ETS and MSR. The key issues the RSB addressed were the insufficient analysis of the problems; the presentation of the specific objectives not in 'SMART' terms; the unclear explanation of the rationale behind the packaging of measures into options; the missing link to the 2040 climate target; and the policy options' lack of details and quantification of costs and benefits. The IA explains how the concerns have been addressed (Part 2, pp. 5‑7). Although some of the issues identified by the RSB have been addressed, the IA still remains largely unclear and hard to understand for decision makers. For example, the IA is not properly streamlined; many repetitions remain; and the costs and benefits are not sufficiently quantified.
Coherence between the Commissions's legislative proposal and IA
The Commission's legislative proposals appear to be broadly in line with the IA's preferred policy option, albeit with some differences. The EU ETS Directive proposal follows policy measure CAP4 for the cap and not measure CAP2, a measure chosen under the preferred PO2, without detailed explanation about a different choice. In addition, the proposal integrated measure CR4 regarding permanent domestic carbon removals instead of the preferred measure CR1. The proposal's explanatory memorandum does not provide information regarding the CR1 deviation from the recommendations expressed in the IA.
Endnotes
Classification
Policy areas: Ex-ante Impact Assessment
Regions: European Union
Committees: Environment, Climate and Food Safety (ENVI)
Statement on the use of AI
Any AI‑generated content in this text has been reviewed by the author. Perplexity was used to improve the readability of the text and broaden the range of sources available to the author.
Disclaimer
This document is prepared for, and addressed to, the Members and staff of the European Parliament as background material to assist them in their parliamentary work. The content of the document is the sole responsibility of its author(s) and any opinions expressed herein should not be taken to represent an official position of the Parliament.
