Dynamic blocking injunctions for intellectual property rights enforcement in the EU State of play on their use across Member States
Summary
Dynamic blocking injunctions (DBIs) have emerged as an important tool for the enforcement of intellectual property (IP) rights and are used across the EU to tackle existing and future infringements, particularly in the field of online piracy. They allow blocking measures to be extended to new internet locations mirroring infringing content that have been created to circumvent existing orders. While EU law and CJEU case law establish common standards for their application, grounded in the principles of effectiveness, proportionality and fundamental rights protection, national approaches to DBIs remain fragmented. EU institutions and studies recognise their potential to strengthen IP enforcement, but also highlight the importance of legal certainty and proportionality. The lack of harmonisation has affected DBIs' effectiveness and raised questions about the need for further EU‑level action, whilst ensuring an appropriate balance between IP protection and fundamental rights.
Introduction
Internet access has contributed substantially to faster and wider access to information and content. Despite the increasing availability of products and content protected by intellectual property rights (IPR) through lawful channels, IPR infringement remains persistently high.
In 2024, approximately 112 million counterfeit products were detained at the EU external borders. In the online environment, an average of 10 access events to illegally uploaded and streamed copyrighted content were recorded per internet user per month between 2017‑2023.
While the IPR framework within the EU grants rights holders a set of exclusive rights that allow them to decide whether to authorise or prevent the use of their protected content or products, effective enforcement of those rights often remains challenging. To address this, the EU legislator has provided the owners and holders of these rights with a range of measures, procedures and remedies through Directive 2004/48/EC (IPRED), a horizontal instrument regulating all types of IPR, supplemented by relevant provisions contained in other legislative instruments.
Among the remedies Member States may make available to rights holders are blocking injunctions aimed at preventing access to websites and URLs on which IPR‑infringing content is made available. A sub‑category, dynamic blocking injunctions, has also attracted considerable attention, as these can prevent access to new websites that mirror previously blocked websites' content. They are regarded as an effective enforcement tool, particularly in the field of copyright protection, piracy and live events due to their speed and reduced costs compared to long‑term judicial processes.
In May 2026, the European Commission launched a consultation to assess whether a targeted initiative was needed to strengthen the copyright framework to enhance European creativity and innovation. A key pillar of this initiative was the fight against online piracy, which remains a major challenge for rights holders. In the follow‑up consultation launched in September 2026, the Commission asked stakeholders about different options to address piracy effectively. Among the options under consideration are measures to ensure that dynamic injunctions are available to rights holders in all Member States. The potential legislative framework for this is expected in the first quarter of 2027.
Types and scope of blocking injunctions
In essence, blocking injunctions are orders aimed at preventing or ceasing an IPR infringement by requiring an intermediary to apply technical measures to halt or disable access to a specific internet location, such as a website. An injunction can be put in place via domain name system (DNS)1 blocking, IP address blocking or URL filtering. A blocking injunction is requested and granted when the intermediary's services are used by the infringer to make available or broadcast IPR‑infringing content. The injunctions block the source of the infringing content but do not necessarily require removal of the content itself, although they may provide for both measures. In principle, therefore, the content may remain available online, but users' access to it is prevented.
Rights holders' ability to seek an injunction against an intermediary is independent of any liability on the part of that intermediary, as illustrated in Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (Digital Services Act), and does not affect the availability of any other sanctions or remedies. The nature of an intermediary's activity as a hosting or access provider is irrelevant for the purposes of issuing an injunction.
Blocking injunctions are regarded as a rapid and relatively secure solution for the effective protection of those rights. This is because identifying the direct infringers often proves ineffective due to constant location change and the time required for their identification. By contrast, measures targeting internet service providers offer a more reliable means of ensuring that access to infringing content is blocked.
Dynamic blocking injunctions
Dynamic blocking injunctions (DBIs) are a sub-category of blocking injunctions. While there is no legal definition of DBIs in EU law, they are defined as orders drafted in a way that allows for more flexibility so they can cover future, repeated infringements, alongside current ones. In this way, DBIs offer a higher level of protection for rights holders. An example is where an injunction blocks a particular domain name, but the third party circumvents the injunction by making the same content available under a new domain name or IP address. A 'static' blocking injunction would not extend to new URLs, thus requiring a new blocking injunction each time. Conversely, the same DBI would cover this new domain name and IP address, as the activity is functionally equivalent to the initially identified misconduct. DBIs are granted by the courts or national administrative authorities and can cover either the same content infringed repetitively, or the same infringer, or both the same infringer and infringed content.
Dynamic blocking injunctions generally apply to intermediaries operating in the relevant Member State territory and to IPR infringements directed to users in this country. They are usually granted as temporary measures for a limited period. This may be a defined period of time during which live events take place, such as sports tournaments, or a period intended to address the emergence of new websites mirroring the infringing site. Rights holders may also request a DBI renewal or extension, and the court will assess whether extension is justified.
Live blocking injunctions
Another subtype of blocking injunctions is live blocking injunctions, which enable repeated blocking of a site whenever a live broadcast takes place, and may also extend to other sites or servers that subsequently broadcast or display the same content. This kind of injunction is only valid while the site provides access or displays the infringing content; it stops blocking the site once infringement stops. This remedy is also considered effective for ensuring swift action against the unauthorised transmission of live events, while providing a proportionate remedy that matches the short lifespan of live streams and strikes a fair balance between fundamental rights.
These categories are not mutually exclusive; a live blocking injunction may also have a dynamic character when it allows additional internet locations to be blocked during the period covered by the order.
EU legal framework
The Union legal framework refers to injunctions in a series of legislative texts. Firstly, in Article 18(1) of the e‑Commerce Directive, Member States are called upon to ensure the rapid adoption of measures, including interim measures, designed to terminate any alleged infringement and prevent further impairment of the interests involved. Article 14(3) also allows Member States to empower administrative authorities (alongside judicial ones) to issue blocking decisions. In Recital 45, the directive clarified that exemptions to intermediary service providers' liability do not affect the possibility of injunctions aimed at terminating or preventing infringement.
The Digital Services Act (DSA) amended the e‑Commerce Directive's framework governing intermediary liability. The DSA also establishes rules governing orders to act against illegal content and preserves the possibility of injunctions under applicable Union and national law. Recital 45 of the e‑Commerce Directive is captured in Recital 25 of the DSA. Article 9 of the DSA establishes a framework for orders issued by national judicial or administrative authorities, requiring that intermediary service providers act against specific items of illegal content. Furthermore, Article 51(2)(b) empowers Digital Services Coordinators to order the cessation of infringements and, where appropriate, to impose or request that judicial authorities impose proportionate remedies to bring the infringement to an end. Article 51(2)(e) further provides for interim measures where necessary to avoid the risk of serious harm. Article 51(3)(b) also permits a Digital Services Coordinator to request that a judicial authority order the temporary restriction of access to a service or online interface when the intermediary has not taken any action to terminate the infringement and the infringement constitutes a criminal offence involving threat to the life or safety of persons. At EU level, Article 70 grants the Commission power to order interim measures against very large online platforms (VLOPs) and very large online search engines (VLOSEs) in urgent cases due to the risk of serious harm for recipients of the service. Such a decision is time‑limited and can only be renewed when necessary and appropriate.
Article 8 of Directive 2001/29/EC (InfoSoc Directive) further requires Member States to enable rights holders to apply for an injunction against intermediaries' services where these are used by a third party to infringe copyright or related rights.
A key instrument for IPR, IPRED refers to the possibility of injunctions in two articles. Firstly, in Article 9, as a provisional and precautionary measure, noting that an interlocutory injunction may be issued against an intermediary whose services are being used by a third party to infringe IP. The same provision also refers to the InfoSoc Directive and injunctions against intermediaries whose services are being used for copyright infringements.
Secondly, Article 11 of IPRED provides for the possibility of judicial authorities to issue permanent injunctions as a final remedy aimed at terminating the IPR infringement when this has been identified by the court. The same provision also stipulates that rights holders can apply for such an injunction against intermediaries if their IPR are infringed by third parties, without prejudice to the InfoSoc Directive's provision. Article 3 further specifies that all measures laid down in the directive shall be 'fair and equitable and shall not be unnecessarily complicated or costly, or entail unreasonable time‑limits or unwarranted delays', which sets out the key conditions under which DBIs can be granted.
As IPRED does not explicitly provide for DBIs but solely refers to injunctions in general, in a resolution of 19 May 2021 the European Parliament called on the Commission to assess the impact and appropriateness of dynamic and live blocking injunctions to allow real‑time blocking or removal of unlawfully broadcasted sporting live content. The Commission subsequently affirmed the effectiveness and alignment of these injunction types with the existing Union legal framework as long as necessary safeguards are in place.
In its 2023 Recommendation on combating online piracy of sports and other live events, the Commission acknowledged the importance of DBIs in combating piracy of live events transmitted online, enabling them to extend to newly launched pirate websites that display the infringing content. This recommendation strongly encourages Member States that have not yet done so to introduce and use DBIs for the transmission of live events. The recommendation also advises Member States to adopt a methodology for updating the list of internet locations covered by the injunction and grant sport organisers legal standing to take legal action directly. Overall, it urges Member States to facilitate judicial practices ensuring that blocking measures remain effective where infringing services change domains or other technical identifiers during the injunction period. The Commission's 2023 recommendation explicitly addresses judicial oversight, appeal rights, avoiding excessive blocking, removing restrictions when infringement ceases, and limiting injunctions to what is necessary.
It has been suggested that the legal foundation for DBIs and live blocking injunction can be found in Article 11 of IPRED, read together with Article 8(3) of the InfoSoc Directive and Article 18 of the e‑Commerce Directive. According to this view, Article 11 of IPRED not only introduces injunctions but also supports their evolution and adaptation to ensure continued effectiveness, including for the online transmission of live events.
The 2024 Recommendation on measures to combat counterfeiting and enhance the enforcement of IPR adopts a similar approach by encouraging Member States to provide for DBIs, as they can be extended to IPR infringements not yet identified when an injunction is applied for.
CJEU conditions for dynamic blocking injunctions
While the scope and conditions for granting such injunctions are largely left to Member States' discretion, as reflected in Recital 23 of IPRED, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has developed common principles for injunctions against intermediaries to ensure effectiveness, proportionality and protection of fundamental rights. However, EU law does not establish a fully harmonised regime specifically governing dynamic blocking injunctions.
The CJEU has noted that these measures do not only aim to terminate an existing infringement but also prevent future similar ones. Additionally, the Court has interpreted the notion of intermediary broadly, explaining that an intermediary can be anyone as long as they provide a service that one or more persons can use to infringe IPR, thus covering internet access service providers. The infringer and the intermediary do not need to be contractually connected for the latter to be covered by the scope of the provisions.
The court injunction does not need to describe concrete technical measures. However, the measures must not unnecessarily deny users access to lawfully available information, and they should prevent, or at least seriously discourage, users from accessing infringing content, without unduly interfering with lawful access.
Before an injunction is granted, the court should strike a balance between the different fundamental rights at stake, including the protection of IPR, the right to freedom to conduct businesses and the right to freedom of information and expression. Internet access providers' services should not be unreasonably restricted, as enshrined in Article 3 of the Open Internet Regulation.2 However, such restrictions can be imposed if they are necessary for the service provider to comply with Union law.
Furthermore, a blocking injunction cannot require an internet service provider to put in place a general monitoring system. The CJEU has also clarified that national law cannot make injunctions dependent upon unreasonable procedural hurdles, such as requiring repeated infringements before relief becomes available. To sum up, the requested measures should be fair, proportionate, non‑abusive, and should not impose excessive costs.
Dynamic blocking injunctions: implementation across EU Member States
The availability of DBIs across the EU remains fragmented to date, as not all Member States have introduced this type of tool or comparable measures into their national legal systems.3 Belgium, France, Greece and Italy expressly provide DBIs as remedies in law. Ireland, Spain and the Netherlands do not expressly provide for DBIs in their legislation, but their IP frameworks allowing injunctions against intermediaries whose services are used to infringe IPR, together with judicial practice in these countries (e.g. Ireland, Spain and the Netherlands), have supported the adoption of DBIs. Overall, the forms taken by DBIs vary widely across Member States.
In Belgium, Ireland, Spain, France, Greece, Italy and the Netherlands, DBIs are granted only in copyright infringement cases. Germany does not provide for a specific legal framework regulating DBIs, but its broader provision on blocking measures allows rights holders to seek the blocking of access to information transmitted through a digital service used to infringe IPR only where no other means of remedying the infringement is available. The blocking must also be reasonable and proportionate. Finland permits blocking orders where substantial amounts of allegedly infringing material are made available without the rights holder's consent, or where the rights holder's rights would otherwise clearly be severely prejudiced. Applicants must explain how they have identified the alleged infringer. Under Finnish law, the order must be reasonable in light of all affected parties' rights.
The Netherlands provides for court‑issued orders and a voluntary website blocking covenant. This is a covenant held between rights holders, represented by the Dutch Federation of Copyright Interests (Federatie Auteursrechtbelangen), the BREIN Foundation, whose objective is to fight IP violation, and various internet access providers, to expedite blocking of websites hosting copyright infringing content. Denmark relies heavily on soft law measures, with the implementation of DBIs supported by a code of conduct agreed between the Telecom Industry Association and rights holders – coordinated by their association, the Danish Rights Alliance.
Alongside courts' competence to issue DBIs, several Member States have also empowered administrative authorities to grant, enforce or update these orders. This is the case in Spain,4 France,5 Greece, 6 Italy7 and Lithuania.8 Italy, Greece, Lithuania and Portugal have also put in place technical tools to support the blocking of the infringing websites, including automated systems to update and monitor the orders. In Belgium, the dynamic character and effectiveness of blocking measures are supported by the competent administrative authority after the court has issued the DBI. As reported in the Commission's study following up on IPRED's application, stakeholders tend to agree that empowering administrative authorities to issue DBIs speeds up and makes the process more cost‑effective.
The duration of DBIs as well as the time frames within which a DBI is granted and enforced also vary across Member States. In France, courts may grant injunctions covering unlawful transmission of sporting events for up to 12 months. In Finland, a blocking order is issued for a fixed period of no more than one year at a time. In Ireland, the duration of an injunction must be 'reasonable', according to the country's jurisprudence, whereas in Lithuania injunctions may remain in force for the entire duration of the infringement. By contrast, Belgium, Spain and Italy reportedly impose no uniform statutory temporal limit on DBIs' validity. Nevertheless, when blocking systems reach their maximum capacity, Italian administrative authority AGCOM may order the unblocking of IP addresses and domain names that have been blocked for at least six months, thereby freeing up capacity for new blocks.
With regard to the time frames for issuing and enforcing DBIs, in Italy internet providers are required to block websites within 30 minutes of the validation of a report filed by the competent authority. Similarly, in Greece, internet providers with more than 20 000 subscribers must comply with blocking orders from the competent administrative authority within 30 minutes of notification. In Belgium, the competent court is required to deliver its decision within eight days. In Spain, the domain name infringing the content must be cancelled by the registration authority for at least six months.
As noted, it is for Member States to further define the conditions under which DBIs are granted. An overview of the different provisions shows that the most common requirements9 include proving that the applicants are rights holders or entitled to apply for measures, that there is an IPR infringement, that the intermediary targeted by the blocking injunction is indeed providing access to the protected content, that there is or will be serious damage caused by the infringing activity, and that the requested measure is proportionate, appropriate and reasonable. The last criterion will need to be decided on a case‑by‑case basis, with courts balancing other potential fundamental rights at stake.
Stakeholder reactions
Stakeholder views on whether DBIs should be retained and further harmonised across the EU, or whether their wider use could pose risks to the functioning of the internet and fundamental rights, vary significantly.
The Association of Commercial Television (ACT) has expressed its support for dynamic blocking injunctions, considering them an extremely effective tool for protecting copyright and related rights. It has also highlighted the need for such a tool to be available and equally practicable in all EU Member States. A similar view has been expressed by the Audiovisual Anti‑Piracy Alliance (AAPA).
On the other hand, while the DSA was still under negotiation, a coalition of associations representing technology platforms argued that removing illegal content at source should be prioritised over blocking intermediaries. They contended that blocking should only be used as a last resort, where the service or platform recipient (e.g. the uploader of the illegal content) has failed to take action. Such injunctions, the coalition noted, should only be mandated by a court or public authority, with full respect for fundamental rights safeguards and reimbursement of the costs incurred by the internet intermediaries concerned. CCIA, the Computer & Communications Industry Association, which was part of the aforementioned coalition, has since expressed serious concerns about the use of DBIs to combat online piracy. In particular, it argues that these measures can be blunt instruments and may be unable to reliably distinguish between unlawful and lawful content.
European Digital Rights (EDRi), a network of civil and human rights organisations across Europe, has stressed the need for meaningful review of injunctions to ensure that their necessity and proportionality can be assessed and challenged. It warns that, particularly in the rapidly evolving online environment, insufficient review mechanisms could lead to disproportionate blocking measures. EDRi has also argued that further harmonisation of blocking measures at EU level is neither necessary nor appropriate at this stage, raising concerns about national sovereignty, legal certainty and predictability, particularly for smaller online intermediaries operating across borders.
Outlook
Since the Study on dynamic blocking injunctions in the EU was carried out by EUIPO in 2021, further developments have been observed across EU Member States. Dedicated authorities and mechanisms have been put in place to support judicial authorities in issuing, monitoring and assessing their implementation. These developments can also be attributed to the 2023 Recommendation on combating online piracy of sports and other live events, which recognises DBIs as a particularly effective tool for addressing the unlawful broadcasting of live events provided that appropriate safeguards are in place. The Commission's 2025 assessment of the recommendation's implementation likewise recognises the importance of DBIs.
While several stakeholders and the EU institutions increasingly recognise their effectiveness, DBIs are not without controversy. Some commentators have raised concerns over their broad nature, the lack of specific limits governing their use and their potential incompatibility with other fundamental rights. Conversely, others explain that these measures are informed by the need to ensure proper enforcement of IPR, subject to a fair balance test, as 'static' blocking injunctions are easily circumvented.
The fragmentation in the availability of DBIs at Member State level, as well as differences in their scope, legal thresholds and procedural safeguards, create legal uncertainty around their application and cross‑border enforcement. This means that online IPR infringements may be addressed effectively in some Member States but not in others. The ineffective implementation of DBIs by courts also remains a persistent issue. Some countries are deemed to strictly apply the subsidiarity principle, by requiring rights holders to take action against the primary infringer instead of the intermediaries, such as in Germany.
The Commission's 2026 study on the application of IPRED notes the need for greater consistency in the application and enforcement of DBIs across the EU, in an effort to tackle the current fragmentation. The study also observes that when DBIs depend on administrative authorities or soft law arrangements, they appear to be more effective than when the courts order them.
A binding Union‑level legislative instrument, which will include minimum standards for when and how to issue DBIs, has been recommended to provide further legal clarity and harmonisation. It has also been suggested that the updated technological blocking tools and judicial or administrative remedies should be coupled with initiatives by rights holders to enhance the availability and affordability of their products and content through lawful channels, accompanied by consumer‑focused campaigns raising awareness of these lawful alternatives. This suggestion has turned into a strong recommendation from the Commission to rights holders, as also indicated in its Recommendation on combating online piracy of live content.
Main references
- EY‑Technopolis Consortium, Follow-up study on the application of the Directive on the Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights, European Commission, March 2026.
- Frosio, G. and Bulayenko, O., Study on Dynamic Blocking Injunctions in the European Union, EUIPO, 2021.
- Karttunen, S., Online piracy of live events, EPRS, European Parliament, December 2025.
- Live Event Piracy Discussion Paper: Challenges and good practices from online intermediaries to prevent the use of their services for live event piracy, EUIPO, 2023.
- Mapping report on national remedies against online piracy of sports content, European Audiovisual Observatory, 2021.
- Riccio, G. M., Countering online piracy of sports and broadcast in the EU, European Parliament, July 2026.
Endnotes
Statement on the use of AI
Any AI‑generated content in this text has been reviewed by the author. ChatGPT and Claude were used to broaden the range of sources available to the author.
Disclaimer
This document is prepared for, and addressed to, the Members and staff of the European Parliament as background material to assist them in their parliamentary work. The content of the document is the sole responsibility of its author(s) and any opinions expressed herein should not be taken to represent an official position of the Parliament.
