Better protection for laying hens and broilers
Issues at stake
-
The 'End the Cage Age' European Citizens' Initiative (ECI) gathered 1.4 million signatures, and the public consultation strongly supported going cage‑free.
-
The European Commission has announced its intention to modernise European Union (EU) animal welfare legislation since 2020, to align rules with the latest scientific evidence. Following the ECI, the Commission committed to proposing a phase‑out of cages for the species concerned. Moreover, the livestock strategy of 7 July 2026 announced a targeted revision of the rules on laying hens and broilers by the end of 2026, focusing on phasing out cages, establishing practical on‑farm welfare indicators, ending the systematic killing of male chicks, and having World Trade Organization‑compatible equivalent requirements for imports.
-
Since 2021, European Parliament has consistently called for a science‑based, species‑by‑species phase‑out of cages, possibly by 2027, with adequate transition periods, financial support for farmers, and EU welfare standards applied to imported animal products.
-
Some Member States in the Council have repeatedly urged the Commission to revise the animal welfare rules in response to the 'End the Cage Age' initiative, and to work towards an EU‑wide end to the killing of male chicks. Several Member States have already acted on their own.
-
Industry associations accept the move towards cage‑free farming and away from culling male chicks, but call for gradual transitions, financial support, flexibility,and no new reporting obligations. Animal welfare non‑governmental organisations and veterinarians argue that a faster transition is feasible if backed by EU funding and harmonised rules. All sides agree that imports must meet equivalent welfare standards.
Purpose statement
This European Parliamentary Research Service paper aims to inform Members on issues related to a forthcoming Commission initiative. It highlights the main choices which may shape the initiative and which Members may wish to explore ahead of formal Commission adoption. Based on documentary and other sources, it reflects the information available at the time of writing.
For further information on the topic, Members and staff of the European Parliament may contact the author(s).
Developments and insights – European Commission
The European Commission's work to modernise European Union (EU) animal welfare legislation began in 2020, with the 'farm to fork' strategy, when a revision of the rules to bring them into line with the latest scientific evidence was announced.
The preparatory work covered:
-
the directive on the protection of animals kept for farming purposes (Council Directive 98/58/EC);
-
the four directives setting minimum standards for laying hens (Council Directive 1999/74/EC), broilers (Council Directive 2007/43/EC), pigs (Council Directive 2008/120/EC) and calves (Council Directive 2008/119/EC);
-
the regulations on animal protection during transport (Council Regulation (EC) No 1/2005) and at the time of killing (Council Regulation (EC) No 1099/2009).
It also considered possible new rules on animal welfare labelling.
In 2021, the Commission published an inception impact assessment setting out the policy options under consideration. That same year, the Commission responded positively to the 'End the Cage Age' European Citizens' Initiative (ECI), and committed to proposing a phase‑out of cages for the species concerned. The fitness check of the current legislation, concluded in September 2022, confirmed the need to revise and modernise the rules. The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), at the Commission's request, adopted a series of scientific opinions, including on the welfare of broilers and laying hens on farms in 2023.
With the final aim of bringing together public entities and private stakeholders from the animal welfare sector, the Commission established the EU platform on animal welfare, which also included thematic subgroups. The sub-group on the welfare of poultry was established in March 2022 to provide technical expertise and opinions to the Commission, taking into account the latest scientific evidence, the objective to phase out cages, and the need to easily enforce the legislation, with the final aim of revising the current legal framework.
The revision of the on‑farm rules was relaunched with the February 2025 Commission communication on a vision for agriculture and food. The vision confirmed the plan to phase out cages, based on the latest scientific findings and in close engagement with farmers, the food supply chain and civil society, with support and transition periods tailored to each species. It also announced closer alignment of the standards applied to imports and the possible introduction of targeted welfare labelling.
The preparation of the Commission's impact assessment included a call for evidence in summer 2025, which received more than 700 responses, as well as targeted surveys, interviews and workshops. It also included a public consultation from September to December 2025 gathering 236 520 contributions. The consultation showed strong support for cage‑free farming and for equivalent standards on imports, with business nevertheless calling for clearer and more consistent EU rules. Building on these results, the Commission's livestock strategy of 7 July 2026 announced a targeted revision of the rules on laying hens and broilers by the end of 2026. It would focus on phasing out cages, introducing practical on‑farm welfare indicators, ending the systematic killing of male chicks, and setting World Trade Organization (WTO)‑compatible equivalent requirements for imports.
A similar revision for welfare of pigs is planned for the second quarter of 2027.
Why is the initiative important?
Public concern about animal welfare has grown steadily. In 2020, the Commission validated the 'End the Cage Age' ECI, which had gathered 1.4 million signatures, and in 2021, the Commission committed to proposing the phasing out of cages for the species concerned. In 2023, a Eurobarometer survey on attitudes of Europeans towards animal welfare showed that 84 % of respondents believe that the welfare of farmed animals should be better protected in their country than it is now.
The Commission's 2022 fitness check of EU animal welfare legislation concluded that the current rules have improved the welfare of the animals they cover, but that welfare in the EU remains suboptimal overall. In particular, the rules still allow animals to be kept in cages and other confined systems that significantly restrict their movement. The rules on laying hens date back to 1999, and those on broilers to 2007 – the proposal expected by the end of 2026 is therefore the first opportunity in two decades to update them. The directives are often 'inadequate, too vague, or providing exceptions or derogations to requirements', as stated in the European Parliamentary Research Service (EPRS) evaluation of the animal welfare directives in 2021.
The fitness check found that the rules are lagging behind scientific evidence and still allow practices, such as beak trimming, now known to be harmful. Although the ban on battery cages from 2012 was a major step forward for around 360 million laying hens, almost half of them (48 %) were still kept in enriched cages in 2020. For broilers, the main welfare problems are linked to breeding for fast growth, stocking density, and lighting conditions to limit aggressive behaviour.
The fitness check also pointed to growing ethical concern over the systematic killing of male day-old chicks in the laying hen sector. Moreover, it noted that, in the case of eggs and egg products, differing welfare standards may cause trade diversion and production relocation. In the EU–Mercosur agreement, for the first time, the EU has granted duty‑free access to certain eggs only if they are produced in line with EU laying hen welfare standards, showing how welfare standards are becoming part of trade policy.
However, change comes at a cost, and this cost is mainly borne by farmers. The cage ban of 2012 was the largest compliance cost in the poultry sector. Compliance costs for the Laying Hens Directive were estimated at €592 million, of which €440 million were one‑off costs. Costs for the Broilers Directive were lower, at around €35.8 million per year for producers.
The public consultation on the modernisation of the EU's on‑farm animal welfare rules, whose factual summary report was published in February 2026, shows that citizens overwhelmingly support phasing out cages for laying hens. Almost all of them considered this important or very important, and only a negligible share saw it as unimportant. Among the barriers to a cage‑free transition, respondents most often cited high investment costs. Respondents were also nearly unanimous in finding the systematic killing of day‑old male chicks in the egg sector ethically problematic. The vast majority considered the adoption of alternatives to this practice a very urgent matter.
Member State positions
In 2020, the German and French ministries of agriculture committed to ending the practice of killing male chicks by the end of 2021, and acted accordingly.
At the Council meeting of July 2021, Germany and France, supported by Ireland, Spain, Luxembourg, Austria and Portugal, asked the European Commission for an impact assessment evaluating a possible EU‑wide ban on the systematic killing of male chicks. In October 2021, the Danish delegation, on behalf of the Belgian, Danish, German, Netherlands and Swedish delegations, presented an information note on 'Updating animal welfare legislation in the EU', supporting a revision of the animal welfare framework, also in relation to the 'End the Cage Age' ECI.
During the Agriculture and Fisheries Council meeting on 17 and 18 October 2022, the German and French delegations, on behalf of the Belgian, German, Irish, French, Cyprus, Luxembourgish, Austrian, Portuguese and Finnish delegations, presented a paper calling for an EU‑wide ban on the systematic killing of male chicks. While recognising that the implementation of alternatives represents a major challenge for the sector, the note also asked the Commission to perform an impact assessment with the final goal of ending the practice. The paper noted that some Member States (namely Germany, France, Italy, Luxembourg and Austria) have already banned the procedure, and that an exchange of experience had already taken place during the meeting of the Chief Veterinary Officers of the EU in January 2022.
In December 2024, the Swedish delegation, supported by Denmark, Germany, Austria, Slovenia and Finland, called on the Commission to advance the proposals on animal welfare and to commit in response to the 'End the Cage Age' ECI.
More recently, following the adoption of the livestock strategy by the European Commission, ministers underlined that the EU needs to reinforce its strategic autonomy and food security. They called for a livestock sector that is more competitive, resilient and sustainable, alongside further improvements in animal health and welfare.
Interested parties' opinions
A study, commissioned in 2022 by Copa-Cogeca – representing farmers and agri‑cooperatives in the EU – notes that 55‑60 % of EU laying hens are already cage‑free. However, it questions the welfare and efficiency of alternative systems, citing higher mortality (laying hens, for example, may be exposed to wild bird diseases), more feather pecking and higher costs. It estimates that banning enriched cages would require around €3.2 billion in investment, reduce the flock to 330‑379 million hens, and squeeze farm margins, particularly in eastern Member States. The effects on the EU egg market would nevertheless be limited: production would fall by 0.5‑2 %, and prices would rise by 3.7 %, with a smaller impact if the transition lasts 10 to 20 years. Copa‑Cogeca is open to a wider use of animal welfare indicators, and supports voluntary certification schemes based on them. However, it opposes any new legislation requiring farmers to collect or report these indicators systematically. Before any EU‑wide initiative, Copa‑Cogeca asks the Commission to support digital tools, recognise existing indicator‑based systems, use the indicators to improve farm management (and not to impose sanctions), avoid new reporting obligations, streamline permits, and ensure that imports meet equivalent standards.
In April 2023, the European Poultry Breeders (EPB) and the European Forum of Farm Animal Breeders (EFFAB) released a joint statement focusing on the 'End the Cage Age' ECI. The associations argue that individual housing of pure-line birds is still needed to collect reliable data, control mating and preserve genetic diversity, and that banning it without viable alternatives could harm welfare, slow genetic progress, and threaten minor species such as quail. They call for a gradual transition, including with Commission support for research, progress reviews every five years, sufficient time before cage‑free breeding becomes mandatory, and identical requirements for imports.
In their November 2025 position paper, the European live poultry and hatching egg sector association (ELPHA), Copa‑Cogeca, the European Union of Wholesale in Eggs, Egg Products, Poultry and Game (EUWEP) and EFFAB say the poultry sector is ready to move away from culling day‑old male layer chicks, and they see in-ovo sexing as the most viable and scalable alternative. They stress, however, that the technology is costly, so retailers and consumers must be willing to share the cost through their purchasing choices. The associations oppose an outright ban, arguing that culled male chicks should still be allowed where they serve a sustainable purpose, such as feed for zoos, birds of prey and other wildlife under conservation programmes. They ask EU policymakers for clear guidance that gives Member States flexibility, a level playing field with imports, national impact assessments during implementation, and a communication campaign to show consumers the added value of these eggs.
In a joint position of July 2026, the poultry sector associations AVEC (representing the European poultry meat sector), ELPHA and EPB support practical welfare indicators that are science‑based, focus on outcomes for the animals, and are designed for continuous improvement rather than sanctions or rankings. As a first step, they propose a few indicators already in use, such as footpad dermatitis, mortality rates, and slaughterhouse findings. They also call for a pilot testing, impact assessment, transition periods and support, and for the indicators to be usable for checking that imports meet equivalent standards.
A study commissioned by AVEC (not yet published at the time of writing) finds that, in 2024, broiler production costs in Argentina, Brazil, Thailand, Ukraine and the United States (among the main exporters of poultry meat to the EU) were 28‑44 % lower than in the EU. EU on‑farm welfare rules do not apply to imports, which must meet equivalent standards only at slaughter, and on‑farm broiler rules in these countries are mostly less strict than in the EU. Higher‑welfare systems remain costly and niche.
In an October 2026 policy brief, 'No double standards', the animal welfare non‑governmental organisations Eurogroup for Animals and World Animal Protection call for imported chicken to be allowed on the EU market only if they meet welfare standards equivalent to the revised EU rules. These standards should cover the whole production chain, not just slaughter. Pointing at high stocking densities and weak legislation in major exporting countries such as Brazil and Thailand, they ask for a dedicated import‑equivalence provision, verification at the level of individual establishments, audits, and suspension powers. They argue that such measures are compatible with WTO rules.
The April 2026 Eurogroup for Animals report, 'Phasing out cages in the EU: the road to a smooth transition', based on stakeholder interviews held in 2022 and 2025 and on scientific evidence, concludes that most systems can make a sustainable transition within three to five years. Producers face real costs from new or renovated buildings and from keeping fewer animals, so fair prices and EU financial support are essential. Many farmers report equal or lower mortality in cage‑free systems, clear welfare benefits and greater job satisfaction. The main bottleneck is environmental permits to build or renovate facilities, which take two to three years on average, and the report calls for faster procedures. Pointing to consumer support and an increasingly fragmented market, it also calls for harmonised EU legislation, arguing that European producers are ready for the transition.
A 2026 report by the Institute for European Environmental Policy (IEEP), commissioned by Compassion in World Farming and Eurogroup for Animals, concludes that the transition to cage‑free farming is technically feasible. The main obstacle is the upfront investment, with financing the key constraint. For laying hens, production costs are estimated at around 22 % higher in barn or aviary systems, and 34 % higher in free‑range systems than in enriched cages. According to the report, 'CAP [common agricultural policy] funding alone is unlikely to be sufficient to cover the scale, speed, and distributional impacts of an EU wide shift to cage‑free systems'. The report calls, among other things, for clear transition periods, national transition plans, and a mix of CAP funds, State aid and loans. In September 2026, the IEEP published a report that assesses how the CAP proposals for 2028 to 2034 could support the transition to cage‑free farming, focusing on laying hens.
The Federation of Veterinarians of Europe (FVE), in 2021, pointed out that enriched cages prevent laying hens from performing their natural behaviours. It calls on veterinarians to lead the transition to alternative systems by improving welfare in existing systems and helping to develop better ones. The federation favours a gradual transition with a reasonable, but not excessive, transition period. New systems should meet the animals' physical and behavioural needs, ensure food safety, limit the use of veterinary medicines, and be economically and environmentally viable. Already in 2018, FVE called for further research into alternatives to killing unwanted offspring, such as in‑ovo sexing. Where killing cannot be avoided, it must be humane, supervised by veterinarians and carried out by trained staff. Society should also be properly informed about the ethical cost of these practices. In 2018, FVE recommended the routine use of animal‑based indicators on farms, so that health and welfare problems are detected early and corrected quickly, and stressed the key role of veterinarians in this monitoring.
European Parliament views
In April 2021, the European Parliament's Committees on Agriculture and Rural Development (AGRI) and on Petitions (PETI) jointly held a public hearing on the 'End the Cage Age' ECI. The conclusion of the hearing supported a call for a phase‑out of cages for farmed animals, financial support for farmers, and EU animal welfare standards for imported animal products. Parliament's June 2021 resolution on the ECI urged the Commission to incorporate the initiative's demands into its revision of Directive 98/58/EC on the protection of animals kept for farming purposes, in line with the European Green Deal and the 'farm to fork' strategy, with the aim to phase out cage farming with a species‑by‑species approach, while supporting farmers in the transition to higher welfare standards. It also asked the Commission to ensure that all animal products imported into the EU fully comply with the relevant EU rules, including the use of cage‑free systems, and to help farmers raise consumer awareness of the high animal welfare standards already in force.
In October 2021, the resolution on a 'farm to fork' strategy for a fair, healthy and environmentally‑friendly food system called for a legislative proposal from the Commission to phase out cages in EU animal farming, with a possible end date of 2027 to be assessed. The phase‑out should rest on a science‑based impact assessment, include an adequate transition period, and follow a species‑by‑species approach so that each animal is kept in an adequate housing system.
In February 2022, Parliament's resolution on the implementation report on on‑farm animal welfare reaffirms support for the ECI and the 2027 phase‑out, specifically targeting battery cages for laying hens. It also strongly emphasises the need for a clear definition of 'cage', as well as financial support for farmers, long transitions, and a cautious, species‑by‑species approach.
Main references
- European Commission staff working document, fitness check of the EU animal welfare legislation, SWD(2022) 328, 2022.
- Rodenburg, B., van Gerwen, M., Meijer, E. et al., End the cage age: Looking for alternatives, Policy Department for Citizens' Rights and Constitutional Affairs, European Parliament, 2020.
Classification
Policy areas: Agriculture and Rural Development
Committees: Agriculture and Rural Development (AGRI)
Statement on the use of AI
Any AI‑generated content in this text has been reviewed by the authors. Claude was used to improve the readability of the text and summarise long documents.
Disclaimer
This document is prepared for, and addressed to, the Members and staff of the European Parliament as background material to assist them in their parliamentary work. The content of the document is the sole responsibility of its author(s) and any opinions expressed herein should not be taken to represent an official position of the Parliament.
